National Affairs

Initiative 638 Passes Decisively in Washington; Seattle Times Coverage Draws Criticism

Fox News reported that Initiative 638 passed decisively among Washington voters and that the Seattle Times' coverage of trans women in sports drew sharp criticism.

The Continental Gazette standing plate
From the pages of The Continental Gazette.

Fox News reported that Initiative 638 passed decisively among Washington voters. The report, which ran under a headline about the Seattle Times' position on transgender athletes, placed the ballot result alongside criticism of the newspaper's coverage. Fox News's summary did not describe what the initiative would do, give vote totals, or say when the result was known. This account rests on the Fox News report on the Seattle Times' coverage.

According to Fox News, the Seattle Times' coverage of trans women in sports drew sharp criticism for its claims. The report's headline attributed to the newspaper the position that there is "no serious scientific evidence" that trans athletes have an advantage over women. Fox News did not name the critics it referred to, identify the specific articles at issue, or summarize the newspaper's stated reasoning, so those points cannot be confirmed from this report.

The report does not say whether the ballot measure and the newspaper coverage are connected. Fox News presented the two developments together, but the summary available does not state that the initiative addressed sports or that the newspaper's coverage concerned the vote. Readers seeking the measure's text, official results, or the newspaper's original reporting would need to consult those primary materials directly.

This story rests on a single Fox News item, and no other outlet's account of either matter was reviewed. The substance of the Seattle Times' position and the scope of the criticism therefore come only from the headline and summary Fox News provided.

Sources: Fox News: The Seattle Times says there's 'no serious scientific evidence' trans athletes have an advantage over women.

The Continental Gazette • Printed for the Publick

Front Page ✦ More from National Affairs