Dispatches

Doctor Whose Evidence Helped Convict Lucy Letby Was Barred From Treating Patients During Trial

The Guardian reported that the jury was never told that Prof Peter Hindmarsh was barred from practising over concerns for patients' safety.

The Continental Gazette standing plate
From the pages of The Continental Gazette.

According to The Guardian's exclusive report, a senior doctor whose evidence helped to convict Lucy Letby was barred from treating patients during the trial over fears that he posed a risk to their safety. The report was written by David Conn and Felicity Lawrence and published on November 18, 2026.

The doctor is Prof Peter Hindmarsh, a specialist in hormones in children. The Guardian reported that prosecutors held him up as a "pre-eminent expert" in the case, a status the outlet contrasted with the restriction on his practice.

The Guardian reported that the jury was never told that Hindmarsh was barred from practising over concerns for patients' safety. The outlet's summary presents this omission as the central point of its reporting, and the report is identified as an exclusive, meaning no other outlet in the material reviewed for this account has published the same findings.

The available summary does not say when the restriction was imposed, by whom, or what specific concerns about patient safety it addressed. It also does not say whether the restriction remains in place, or whether the court was aware of it at the time of the trial.

The material reviewed also does not include any response from Hindmarsh, from prosecutors, or from other parties named in the trial. The summary is incomplete, ending partway through its description of the restriction, so the account above reflects only the portions of The Guardian's report that were available. Further detail is contained in the full article, which was not available for this account.

Sources: The Guardian: Doctor whose evidence helped to convict Lucy Letby was barred from treating patients during trial.

The Continental Gazette • Printed for the Publick

Front Page ✦ More from Dispatches